It’s ten to six.
You’ve spent half an hour talking a frustrated client round before they walked. You noticed the colleague who went unusually silent in the meeting and checked in with them afterwards. And you spotted the problem in next week’s plan early enough to prevent a rather expensive mess.
You’ve had a good day.
Except nobody really knows what you’ve done.
The client didn’t leave. The colleague is feeling better. The expensive mess never happened.
Everything carried on as normal.
Meanwhile, someone else has just received a lovely email from the boss congratulating them on their bold thinking.
Ah.
Sound familiar?
The strange problem with being good with people
Here’s something I’ve noticed in my work as a psychologist.
Some of the most valuable things empathic people do are also the hardest things to see.
You recognise tension before it becomes conflict. You understand what a client is really worried about. You notice when someone is struggling, even though they’re smiling and telling everyone they’re fine.
You do something about it, and the situation improves.
But what exactly goes into the performance review?
Prevented a disagreement nobody knew was about to happen?
Kept a client who never actually threatened to leave?
Helped three colleagues work together without anyone noticing they weren’t getting along?
Good luck putting a number on that.
And yet organisations spend enormous sums of money trying to teach their leaders to do precisely these things.
Your empathy is doing more than you realise
Empathy has several dimensions, and understanding them helps us appreciate its potential value at work.
Cognitive empathy helps you understand how someone else sees a situation. This can inform how you negotiate, solve problems and make decisions.
Emotional empathy involves feeling with that person. It helps you connect with people and appreciate the emotional impact of what’s happening.
Compassion is the action you take to help alleviate their suffering.
These are different psychological experiences. And having them doesn’t automatically make someone an effective leader.
What matters is how you use them.
Someone who understands a client’s worries may be able to anticipate an objection. Someone who notices the emotional impact of a difficult decision may communicate it more thoughtfully. Someone who cares about others may be motivated to challenge unfair treatment.
There can be real professional value in all of that.
But being valuable and being recognised as valuable are two very different experiences.
I call the distance between what you actually contribute and how other people perceive your value the Credibility Gap.
And there’s a second part to this problem that I find fascinating.
The moments when you make yourself harder to see
Imagine you’re in a meeting.
You’ve spotted a problem with the proposed approach. You know exactly what you want to say.
But then you notice how enthusiastic your colleague is about their idea.
You can almost feel their disappointment before you’ve even opened your mouth.
So you soften your point.
“I might be completely wrong, but perhaps we could also consider…”
You add a few qualifications. You make sure they know you appreciate their work.
And by the time you’ve finished, your perfectly sound professional judgement sounds more like a tentative suggestion.
Nobody asked you to do that.
You did it in anticipation of how somebody else might feel.
This is one way the Empathy Eclipse can show up: your attention shifts towards another person’s feelings or judgement so quickly that your own perspective becomes harder to express.
It can happen when you’re setting a boundary, asking for what you’re worth, disagreeing with someone or deciding whether to take on another person’s workload.
And sometimes the price of avoiding a few uncomfortable minutes is considerably greater than we realise.
Perhaps your opinion carries less weight. Perhaps your own work gets delayed. Perhaps a client never discovers the full value of your expertise.
Of course, these things can also happen because of biased promotion decisions, poor leadership or a workplace that systematically overlooks relational effort. We shouldn’t put the entire responsibility on the person being overlooked.
But I feel I have a duty to help people recognise where they have more choice than they realised.
Here’s something to try this week
The next time your empathy helps you achieve something at work, practise naming the contribution.
Perhaps you say in your own words:
“I picked up on the client’s concerns early, so we were able to resolve them before they affected the project.”
Or, if you’re self-employed:
“I spend time understanding what my clients are worried about, which helps me anticipate problems and offer better advice.”
Notice how different that feels from saying:
“Oh, I just had a chat with them.”
You’re describing the judgement, skill and value behind what you did.
You don’t need to inflate your contribution. Just stop editing it out.
FIRST
Take the Quiz
Discover how your cognitive empathy, emotional empathy and compassion show up at work, and where they may be holding you back.
Free · 2 minutes · No sign-up to see your results
SECOND
Join the Live Masterclass
Too Nice to Get Ahead?
Why empathic professionals are relied upon but overlooked, and how to start getting the recognition and influence you want.
Tuesday 8 December, 7–8pm GMT
Live on Zoom
£27 until Tuesday 1 December
Your empathy has been doing useful things for other people for years.
Let’s see what it could do for you.